The D-pad on the Vilros controller is exactly the same size and shape, but there’s slightly more give to the pad itself so it’s easier to feel when you press the directions that it’s actually responding. I actually like the joysticks of this controller better than the original PS1 or PS2 controller.
https://www.amazon.com/Vilros-Retro-Gaming-Classic-Gamepad/dp/B07K6RPGXY

